I thought I would try this as there was a special at the time. I found it quite different, in that it is textured, not soft and squishy like the others are. I find the textured quality enabled you to use less, in that it is kind of like a "Brillo" concept (but definitely NOT Brillo), making cleaning the butt faster and using less. We have a septic system, which this tp is good for. Septics can take only so much in it, unlike sewers. This breaks down very quickly, which we like, too, also helping the septic.