Looks:I like the dark brown color (Tobacco) and the fit is perfect. I'm 6'1" 195 lbs and I could definitely wear a hoodie underneath without it getting too bulky. No defects at all, same triple stich as others. I like the small Dri-Duck logo on the left hand pocket.Warmness:With just an undershirt, flannel, and the jacket on, I'm comfortable at 40, maybe even 30 degrees F. The hood holds the heat in and is very functional and warm. It's a heavy jacket (4 or 5 lbs) and with the canvas shell and quilted lining, you don't need much else on underneath to stay warm while being active. Being stationary and outside in this jacket may get you feeling a little chilly so add a layer.