These black suede shoes are exactly as advertised, and exactly as I expected.Note that these are a pretty plain oxford. They are not the most stylish shoes in the world, but they look pretty much as the picture shows.They are very light weight. The sole looks to have reasonable thickness (so I am expecting reasonable length of wear). The tread gives a little better traction than I expected it might when first opening the box. Not that it's a grabber; but it's not subject to just completely slipping on a smooth floor and setting you on your tukus.The shoes are quite comfortable - more comfortable than average. The insoles are soft and seem to conform to the shape of my foot pretty well. The uppers are roomy without feeling loose. Hush Puppies tend to be narrower than other shoes; but these are not. The width is just right (I bought the 2E width).So far, I have nothing bad to say about these shoes (which might be a little unusual for me. I can pick on almost anything!). They are comfortable, fit even better than I half-way expected, and look like the pic; so I have no reason to give them other than five starts.I'll see how they wear and how they look after a bit of wear. If I have time, I will try to update my review then.