All in all I really like this shoe. It has a classy look but with just enough flair. It pairs perfectly both with my light grey suit or khakis and a button down shirt. The shoes did come with a few scratches in them, but nothing that a little buffing and product shouldn't take care of.The fit is ok. it's not so much that the shoe is too narrow, but the design, with the elongated toe, causes the shoe to bend (when walking) right where my pinky toe is, so after a few hours it starts to hurt. The opening around the ankle was also a little large, so the shoes have to be tied pretty tight to keep them from moving around the back of my ankle too much, and even then I did get some blisters the first day I wore them. I wore them for the first time to a conference in Anaheim which required a lot of walking, and they did break in well over the course of the weekend, but by the end of the 3rd day, my feet were absolutely killing me, but I think this would be the case with any shoe of this style, and isn't necessarily a criticism of this particular shoe.The shoe did seem to have a lot of wax on it. Over the course of the weekend this seemed to discolor and turn whiter in spots where the leather moved a lot. I'm not sure if this is normal for a shoe like this or not, but it did somewhat detract from the appearance of the shoe.All in all, despite the noted issues, I think this is a solid shoe, especially for the price, and seems well constructed. I also recommend pairing it with the matching Florsheim Men's 32 mm Full Grain Leather Wingtip Belt, to really complete the look.